New Jersey pizzerias have gotten rave reviews from Portnoy in the past. One of the highest scores ever, a 9.4, went to Jersey ...

Carosello's was the only place to repeat a top-five finish in both 2024 and 2025. Winners from the 2024 South Jersey pizza ...

Portnoy has reviewed one pizza place in New Jersey that received an unbelievable score of 9.4! There aren't many pizzas that ...

From a American-Italian to a retro and warm, these local restaurants will melt the frost from your wintry soul.